Rufino's Pizza

Nestled within the bustling St. Augustine Outlet Mall, Rufino's Pizza serves up an authentic slice of New York right here in Florida. Specializing in genuine NY-style thin crust pizzas, this pizza restaurant is a haven for pizza lovers craving that perfect balance of crisp, flavorful crust paired with just the right amount of tangy red sauce and melty mozzarella cheese.

The menu shines with crowd favorites like the Pizza Margherita, a simple yet elegant pie bursting with fresh, vibrant tomato flavors and aromatic basil. For those who want to indulge, the 16” or 18” Pepperoni pizzas stand out with generous layers of perfectly cooked pepperoni that curl up at the edges, releasing a smoky richness with every bite.

Beyond the classic pies, Rufino’s offers delightful unique options such as the creamy White Spinach Pizza and the hearty Sicilian Pizza, each crafted with fresh ingredients daily. Their homemade Garlic Knots, served warm with a tangy marinara dipping sauce, provide the perfect garlicky companion to any meal — whether you grab a smaller trio portion or a full half-dozen to savor with friends or family. For lighter fare, the crisp Garden and Antipasto salads bring a refreshing burst of color and crunch, dressed in choices of blue cheese, ranch, or classic Italian dressing.

Despite being located in a food court setting—which some might expect to be noisy and rushed—Rufino's manages to carve out a welcoming and efficient atmosphere. Customers consistently praise the staff for their friendly and quick service, ensuring your piping hot slice is ready in mere moments. The overall vibe is relaxed, making it an ideal spot for shoppers to recharge with a satisfying meal without the usual wait.

Rufino’s Pizza has earned glowing reviews from patrons who appreciate its authenticity and surprising quality for a mall food court. Imran Khawaja highlights the crisp, flavorful slices and excellent combo deals, while Brian Earle calls it a "hidden gem" and the "best and most authentic NY style pizza in Florida." Even when the food court feels quiet, customers like Melnard Rio find the pizza and service phenomenal, making it a calm oasis to enjoy a genuine Brooklyn-style pie. If you're craving classic New York pizza with approachable prices and a friendly touch, Rufino’s Pizza is an unmissable stop during your visit to St. Augustine outlets.

Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice, sharing a whole pie with friends, or indulging in their garlic knots, Rufino’s brings a heartfelt taste of New York to every bite, making every visit a comforting culinary experience you’ll eagerly return to.